State v. Hobbs, No. A-2010-24 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Oct. 2, 2026). Unpublished, so not binding precedent (R. 1:36-3).
Police investigating six armed gas station robberies in Morris and Warren counties in January 2022 obtained two geofence warrants for Google Location History. One account appeared at all three locations in the second return, and Google identified it as the defendant’s. After his motion to suppress was denied, he pleaded guilty to three first-degree robberies.
The Appellate Division reversed and remanded. The affidavit described the robberies and how phones and Google location data work, but offered nothing tying the suspects to a phone or a Google account. The court held that the fact that cell phones are common cannot by itself establish probable cause; otherwise police could seek a geofence warrant in almost any investigation. It did not reach the defendant’s other arguments (overbreadth, particularity, geofence warrants as general warrants).
Takeaway for affiants: the court said the application could have been strengthened with facts that the suspects used phones to communicate during or around the robberies, or with the affiant’s training and experience that multi-suspect robberies like these typically involve phones, for example for mapping.
The opinion also cites Chatrie v. United States (U.S. June 29, 2026), which held that geofence warrants are Fourth Amendment searches.



